

|
Email this
Print this
Send comment
by Richard McQuillin
If you want a short summary of this article,
see About MakeLifeEasy.
Real Benefits From Online Shopping Are Still Coming
Online shopping ought to be solving a lot more of our problems.
It certainly has the potential to ease our lives. It's just not there yet.
We live in an era of intense advertising stimulus, continous shopping, and heavy consumption.
Here I'm going to describe how to pull merchants in the right direction,
to serve us the way they should, toward relieving some of the burden of these problems.
|
A key benefit of online shopping -- still to come -- will be to
make our purchasing more rational again after decades of emotional persuasion and over-consumption.
|
Online shopping has one real benefit to us consumers:
it keeps us out of the actual stores,
which are brilliantly designed to persuade us into making many poor buying decisions.
The most advanced psychological manipulation techniques available today
are used in modern retail outlets and brought to bear on shoppers with the simple,
singular goal of extracting as much money as possible from us.
But, while online shopping keeps out of of the stores, it has problems of its own.
We simply have a hard time making good purchase decisions when we're not in the store.
Since we're used to getting all these sensory inputs when we're in the store,
we can't make the same decisions staring at a computer screen waiting for pages to download
while we click through a sequence of links trying to fill our carts with the things we need.
But the question is, "Why do we shop that way in the first place?"
The problem is not with either type of shopping,
but with the crazy, irrational, outdated way we purchase products.
Online merchants have simply adapted the old selling techniques to the internet.
We need to break these old habits, and then a lot of these problems will be solved.
Here I'm going to describe some of the benefits we can achieve with the MakeLifeEasy vision.
In brief, you'll be able to simplify your shopping, reduce over-consumption, and gain a little more
relaxation and free time. If you're interested, you'll also help to care for the environment.
This article is long on generalities and short on specifics.
If you want to know exactly how to get started with the first step --
expert shopping -- go to the last section on "How to Get Started".
Who Do Retailers Serve?
Hey, I'm not knocking retailers of any type.
Take your local supermarket, for example. It is - simply put - a miracle of modern civilization.
But modern major retailers, just like all public companies,
are compelled to maximize their sales and profits above anything else.
That's just the way they are.
Most retailers strive to provide value to their customers, too --
but it's always going to be the second priority:
| STORE-SERVING PRIORITIES: |
CUSTOMER-SERVING PRIORITIES: |
1. Maximize sales and profits
2. Serve customers
|
1. Serve customers
2. Maximize sales and profits
|
It may look like a small difference, but it's all the difference in the world.
Retailers always have a built-in "conflict of interest": their owners versus their customers.
Sometimes it's "win-win" situation, but
maximizing the returns to owners often means selling too much to consumers.
An alliance of consumers can help retailers to give higher priority to the needs of their customers.
They need our help to steer them in the right direction. We can't expect them do it on their own.
The Shopper's Treadmill
Here's the "cycle of consumption".
The cycle starts when we need something, or we have some problem.
- Stimulus.
Advertisements, brands, marketing and sales pitches persuade us what to buy.
No matter what problem we have,
someone has a story that if we just purchase and consume what they have to offer,
our problem will be solved,
or our lives will be vastly improved by their new and improved version.
- Shopping. We shop for what we need.
While some shopping is enjoyable, a lot of our shopping is routine, boring, tedious, low-level,
unrewarding, time-consuming re-stocking of our recurring needs for food, personal care, and other supplies.
- Heavy consumption. We are often persuaded to buy the wrong things, more than we need,
and things we don't need at all,
so we suffer the effects of incorrect buying, impulse buying, emotional buying,
and other irrational buying behavior.
- More work, to buy more stuff. We all know what this is like.
We have to make all those mortgage payments, lease payments, credit card payments, etc.
It takes a lot of work.
If work is unsatisfying at times, we listen to sales pitches about things to purchase that will make us happy.
Either way, we're back to square 1, and the cycle continues.
Then there are few other aspects of this process that may or may not concern you:
- Waste. The packaging, remains, junk, and other byproducts of these purchases
are mostly cast off into landfills. Is this a problem?
- Dissatisfaction and Un-fulfillment.
Of course, some purchasing and consumption makes us happy - very happy.
But we're not very happy when we deal with weight problems,
health problems, consumer debt, envy of others' possessions, maintenance costs,
insurance costs, storage costs, worries about theft, worries about loss of possessions or social status,
job loss, etc.
- Big Brother.
The fact is that store scanners, web sites, and related technologies
are collecting data about us at a faster and faster rate. Then, sophisticated
"data mining" techniques are
used to form conclusions about you and what you will buy.
How did we get into these strange shopping habits?
Well, it's partly just a continuation of what we've done for centuries, before the information revolution,
especially the personal information revolution.
Our traditional shopping habits haven't caught up yet with what our personal computers
and the internet can do for us.
This is coupled with a continuation of traditional marketing, advertising, and branding methods
that brilliantly and relentlessly encourage us to purchase and consume as many products as possible.
Here we offer a few comments on some of these elements.
1. Stimulus
The practice of modern marketing is a triumph of applied psychology,
and can't be done justice here.
If you're interested in the evolution of the practice,
you could start by searching the web to read about the genius of marketers like
Ernest Dichter and Alfred P. Sloan.
Unquestionably, these communications industries have done a lot to further the comfort of humankind.
But ultimately they work for the merchants, and their goal is to maximize the merchants' interest.
Whether or not you as a consumer actually benefit is less important.
What we want to do is restore a little balance to the relationship by letting us as consumers
get a little more control. We do this simply by shedding light on some common marketing practices
and by plainly presenting facts -- much in the form of products and prices -- to help you make
unemotional decisions.
For example, here are a couple of points that run throughout the MakeLifeEasy application:
- Branded products are a lot more alike than you would think.
For example, your favorite cold remedy has exactly the same ingredients as about ten others,
some of which may be much less expensive.
- Private label packaged goods are often of superior quality than heavily branded and advertised products.
They are made by the same great companies.
4. More Work to Buy More Stuff
One of the nice things about putting consumption in perspective is that you can
have more time to pursue the things you like.
Owning lots of brand new, shiny possessions is tremendously more expensive
than owning less possessions that are maybe not as new.
And that means you can spend a lot less less time working for
and being preoccupied with your possessions.
Finish college. Get a masters degree. Any kind of learning.
Creative pursuits. Self-expression.
Travel. Get to know your kids. Study any subject you want.
Learn new skills to change jobs, or just for the fun of it.
Develop long-delayed talents.
Start a business you love.
Fall in love.
Save money and watch it grow. Retire early.
You get more freedom to make the decisions you want.
5. Disposal and Environmental Damage
There's a lot of debate on the environmental impact of our consumption.
Some believe it's a serious problem. Others believe we have plenty of landfill space for consumer goods.
Either way, there are several ways that rational purchasing can certainly help to reduce environmental impact:
- When you buy larger quantities, you have less packaging per amount of product.
These benefits can be significant:
The total volume of packaging material for some 48 floz containers of shampoo
is only 90% greater than that of a 16 floz bottle of shampoo.
In other words, you can reduce the packaging you use for this product by over 100% by buying in larger sizes.
If you don't like handling the larger sizes, it's very easy to keep only one smaller container for actual usage;
that is, pour from the 48 floz bottle you purchased into the 16 floz bottle you use for using the shampoo.
You're "re-using" right in your own home, with much bigger environmental benefits than recycling.
- Products that spend time on retail shelves can suffer several possible bad fates including
breakage, spoilage, theft, etc.
Products that go directly from the distribution center to your house will not suffer any of these fates.
It's just more efficient: it reduces the total amount of product needed to satisfy your needs, and reduces waste.
- Less reliance on packaging for selling means less constraints on packaging design.
This can only help to reduce the environmental impact of packaging:
- packages can be smaller and use less material because they're not vying for shelf space
- packages can be smaller because they do not have to carry big brand names or pictures to attract your attention,
- packages need not become obsolete (and prematurely scrapped) because their branding message is obsolete,
- packages can be smaller and simpler because they don't have to meet the demands of retail shelves:
they can go directly from the distribution center to your house.
6. Dissatisfaction and Un-fulfillment
Of course, shopping for and consuming products can often be a great source of pleasure.
If so, great. Enjoy it!
Others may feel that they're not getting the happiness promised,
but perhaps are hooked into a pattern of purchasing and consumption for which they'd like to try an alternative.
If that's you, you might want to experience the joy of NON-consumption!
It is serene, beautiful, and profoundly rewarding. But that's another topic.
Suffice it to say that rationalizing your purchasing can be a big step in that direction, if you're interested.
7. Big Brother
Sophisticated
"data mining" techniques are
used to form conclusions about you and what you will buy.
For example, it's now a known fact that men buy diapers and beer after work on Wednesdays.
Merchants can use this data in a way that's helpful to you, providing what you need when you need it.
It could be nice to walk into a store on Wednesday after work and find beer on sale next to diapers on sale
next to the express checkout counter.
But in other ways this data can be used to pull your strings.
What if the beer is sold at full price, and diapers are also at full price,
on the other side of the store,
and the path between beer and diapers is loaded with expensive snack foods?
You can bet that this information is used to reduce the store's costs
and to get you to spend as much as possible.
The point here is: merchants are gathering more and more data about you, and processing it in more and more
sophisticated ways. Wouldn't it be nice if we could do the same thing?
How about us getting some data about them.
The Vision of Expert Shopping
Did you know that large retailers spend millions of dollars annually on software systems for inventory control?
In 2001-2002, K-Mart alone spent over $1 billion to upgrade its inventory controls and distribution systems.
Merchants spend extravagantly on inventory control systems because they know that
these systems pay for themselves many times over.
They are all part of a planned, rational, expert product purchasing and management system
So let's look at a way that we as consumers could get the same benefits.
- Define Your Needs & Priorities.
The idea here is to raise your "level of involvement" up one level:
Instead of constantly buying the same (or similar) products over and over again,
you specify what you need (your shopping list) and
let the merchant help you pick the product(s) for you.
- Select Merchants or Auctions.
You'll be able to select merchants to fulfill your needs,
or put your needs up for bid at auction.
- Approve & Receive Shipments.
Merchants contact you to let you know that you need replenishment.
You make whatever changes you like, then approve the shipment.
When you receive the shipment, you make sure the receipt is logged in MakeLifeEasy.
- Consume/Use Assets.
Just do what you do!
- Update Assets in MLE.
You occasionally check in and update the status of your assets: specifically, what you have left.
MakeLifeEasy makes it simple, and
usually you can do this step while you're approving your next shipment.
- Get Smarter.
Improve your knowledge and wisdom. MakeLifeEasy provides you with some great knowledge, including:
- Items that you're spending too much on, based on what other members are paying (and where to get these deals)
- Items that you're spending too much on, because you're overusing them (based on how other members use them and on general statistics)
- Items that you're spending too much on because they're lower in your priorities than other items you're spending less on.
- Items offered at great prices that you should buy now because YOU need them.
Here we offer a few comments on some of these steps.
2. Select Merchants or Auctions
You'll be able to either select merchants, or put your needs up for bid at auction.
We believe that long-term agreements with merchants will give you better prices and more satisfaction overall.
Think of a merchant not as place you go to pick and choose over products,
but more like a home management partner with a commitment to serve your needs.
Again, it helps when you remember that many products are just commodities.
3. Approve & Receive Shipments
This system works well when you realize that many products are commodities
-- more or less equivalent -- despite what the ads tell you.
When you start understanding that so many products are commodities,
the whole process of shopping becomes a lot easier.
Take long distance service, for example.
You don't keep shopping for new long distance service each month.
Long distance service is long distance service,
except for the price and terms (like calling plans and times).
You either have a telephone connection or you don't, and one isn't any better than the other.
Or even if one is a little better than the other,
it's not worth going through the bother of switching each time.
So then, why is it worth your time and trouble to pick Tide off the shelf each month? It isn't.
You're just doing it out of habit, and you need a better way. That's what MakeLifeEasy provides.
But the fact is, this system works well even if some products are not equivalent to you,
and you want a specific brand.
That's because you can tell your merchants exactly what matters to you; whether you want:
- The lowest cost heavy-duty laundry detergent (any brand)
- Surf, Tide, or Wisk laundry detergent (the lowest price of these three)
- Tide laundry detergent (only)
Your merchants can provide all the candidates that are important to you,
then you select the one(s) you want, and receive the shipment.
6. Get Smarter
You'll improve your shopping knowledge and develop wisdom over time.
MakeLifeEasy provides you with some great intelligence, including:
- Items that you're spending too much on, based on what other members are paying
(and where to get these deals).
- Items that you're spending too much on, because you're overusing them
(based on how other members use them and on what the manufacturers recommend).
- Items that you're spending too much on because they're lower in your priorities
than other items you're spending less on.
- Items offered at great prices that you should buy now because YOU need them.
How to Get Started
If you're still not sure you want to get freedom from shopping, you could also check out
Do You Want Freedom From Shopping?.
If you believe that getting freedom from shopping is worthwhile,
we need your membership in the MakeLifeEasy alliance
so we can make it happen.
The specific steps to get going are defined in a sister article:
Seven Steps To Freedom From Shopping.
Here is the process in brief:
- Step 1: Decide If You're Ready For Freedom From Shopping
- Step 2: Decide Which Shopping You Want Freedom From
- Step 3: Select Merchants And Get Them Into the Alliance
- Step 4: Design Your Shopping Lists For the Store Types You've Selected
- Step 5: Build Your Database of Shopping and Usage Data
- Step 6: Link Up With Your Preferred Merchants
- Step 7: Use MakeLifeEasy To Purchase and Track Your Assets
Links
Coming in future months:
- Big Brother in the Stores
- Big Brother in the Back Room
Email this
Print this
Send comment
|
|